These gymnasts have won the all-around title at the Pan American Championships.
| 2024 Santa Marta | Michelle Pineda (MEX) |
| 2023 Medellín | Tiana Sumanasekera (USA) |
| 2022 Rio de Janeiro | Flavia Saraiva (BRA) |
| 2021 Rio de Janeiro | Rebeca Andrade (BRA) |
| 2018 Lima | Grace McCallum (USA) |
| 2017 Lima | no all-around final |
| 2016 Sucre | no all-around final |
| 2014 Mississauga | Mykayla Skinner (USA) |
| 2013 San Juan | no all-around final |
| 2012 Medellín | no all-around final |
| 2010 Guadalajara | Kyla Ross (USA) |
| 2008 Rosario | no all-around final |
| 2005 Rio de Janeiro | Chellsie Memmel (USA) |
| 2004 Maracaibo | no all-around final |
| 2001 Cancún | Tasha Schwikert (USA) |
| 1997 Medellín | Denisse Lopez (MEX) |
All items (9)
